In 2008, Alisha Sidie, a 27-year-old mother of two vanishes in a small cabin vacation town in Wisconsin. The whole community mobilises for the search.
In 2013, 17-year-old Alexis Murphy, rising social media star and athlete, disappears along Route 29 with no trace until a security video reveals a chilling clue.
21-year-old Joel Larson is shot to death in a neighbourhood known to be a haven for gay people in 1990's Minneapolis. Soon, more shootings terrorise the community.
In August 1992, Tennessee landowner Allen Roberts arrives home to discover his wife is missing. Suspicion soon falls on him, but is someone else the culprit?
Debora Gail Moody vanishes from her home in Ludowici, Georgia. A decade passes with no answers, until a confession reveals chilling details of her disappearance.
John and Elizabeth Calvert were prominent residents of the upscale Hilton Head, South Carolina, until they vanished in 2008 following a meeting with their accountant.