Episode 1
In 1990, two hunters are found dead in the woods. Eleven-years later, cold case detectives arrest a man for the murders, but the original investigators disagree.
Episode 2
As the investigation into the death of the Michigan hunters continues, doubts linger as to the culprit. Could the detectives have got things wrong?
Episode 3
In 1987, a young girl vanishes in Florida. When her body is found the next morning, investigators suspect the sole cop on duty is responsible.
Episode 4
In 1997, a grandmother is found murdered in her Florida apartment. Family members spend the next 15 years suspecting one of their own kin is responsible.